Core Distinction 313
Darwin and the Victorian Age of Discovery

 

Lectures, Exams, and Reading Assignments
Fall 2007

Textbooks: Appleman, P. ed. 2001. Darwin: A Norton Critical Edition (3rd edition).
Keynes, R. 2001. Annie's Box: Charles Darwin, His Daughter and Human Evolution.
Osborne, R. 1999. The Floating Egg: Episodes in the Making Geology.
 

Week Topic Invited
Lecturer
Date/Field Trip
1
30 Aug
The meaning of fossils & pre-Darwinian ideas about evolution   Hascall Hall and
Linsley Museum in Lathrop Hall

Readings: Appleman text; Gregory's article on Changing Concepts of the Nature and Significance of Fossils: 108-118;
                  The Floating Egg: Ch. 3

Assignment: Choose dates for group and final presentation; What are fossils and explain their cultural significance in the 17th and 18th centuries? (Before our first class meeting, choose two specimens on display in the Linsley Museum and two evident in the building stones of Hascall Hall to explore in greater detail how fossils were interpreted within a nascent scientific-"evolutionary" context before Darwin Ñ pls draw sketches to indicate your specific specimens).


2
6 Sept
UK's prehistoric bestiary & the map that changed the world   8 Sept:
Field trip to Geer Road
"quarry" and to the
Museum of the Earth, Ithaca

Readings: Appleman text; The Floating Egg: x-348

Assignment: In what ways did discoveries of fossils of extinct vertebrates in the UK in the late 18th - early 19th centuries and William Smith's map pave the way for Darwin?

Field Trip Assignment: Compose your 1st letter to Darwin as per instructions given during the field trip (for ideas, refer to Blackboard copy of G. Dover's book, Dear Mr. Darwin: Letters on Evolution of Life and Human Nature); e-copy due next class.


3
13 Sept
Charles Darwin, the voyage of the Beagle, & Annie's box   Local cemetery
(do on own before class)

Readings: Appleman text; Annie's Box:xi-211

Assignment: Selection/discussion of final research topic; Use the cemetery data to explain the influence that rates of juvenile mortality in the Victorian age had on Darwin's emerging ideas about evolution, and explain how Darwin's scientific activities connected to some aspect of his life - (choose one) privileged background; career expectations and disappointments; travels; domestic life; fragile health; delayed publication of his ideas.

Field Trip Assignment: e-copy due at beginning of class (see field trip handout and description above).


4
20 Sept
The Origin of Species   Species & finch exercises

Readings: Appleman text; Annie's Box: 212-297; Mayr's ariticle Darwins's Influence on Modern Thought: 79-83 (available thru Blackboard)

Assignment: Proposal (1 page) of final research paper due; Explain Darwin's concept of "species", his evidence for evolution, and the basis for his ideas about "natural selection"; draft outline due by presenters of next week's group presentation


5
27 Sept
Political ramifications in Victorian Britain v. US   Student presentations

Readings: Appleman text

Assignment: Group presentation by students: In what ways did Darwin's ideas together with the Industrial Revolution - fuel political unrest in the Victorian age (Britain v. US)?; draft outline due by presenters of next class's group presentation


6
4 Oct
Social reform & eugenics in Victorian Britain v. US   Student presentations

Readings: Appleman text

Assignment: Group presentation by students: In what ways did Darwin's ideas - together with the Industrial Revolution - fuel social reformation and the eugenics movement in the Victorian age (Britain v. US)?; draft outline due by presenters of next class's group presentation


7
11 Oct
Expression of Darwinian concepts in literature    

Readings: Appleman text

Assignment: Group presentation by students: How did Victorian writers respond to and resist Darwin's ideas?; draft outline due by presenters of next class's group presentation


8
18 Oct
Expressions of Darwinian concepts in Victorian art and music   Student presentations

Readings: Appleman text

Assignment: Group presentation by students: How did Victorian artists - painters and musicians - respond to and resist Darwin's ideas?; draft outline due by presenters of next class's group presentation


9
25 Oct
Research papers: ethics, sociobiology, and evolutionary psychology R. Keynes1 Video conference with Darwin's great-great-grandson, author of Annie's Box

Readings: Appleman text

Assignment: Draft outline of research paper, 2nd letter to Darwin (3-5 pgs), and annotated reference list due

Field Trip Assignment: Compose your 2nd letter to Darwin as per instructions given during the teleconference (for ideas, refer to Blackboard copy of G. Dover's book, Dear Mr. Darwin: Letters on Evolution of Life and Human Nature); copy due next class

10
1 Nov
Religious reactions in Victorian Britain & the modern creationist movement    

Readings: Appleman text; articles on "intelligent design" (paper copies to be distributed or on Blackboard)

Assignment: What was so "dangerous" about Darwin's ideas, and in what specific ways did Darwin's ideas challenge Christian beliefs in the Victorian age and today?

Field Trip Assignment: teleconference essay due at beginning of class (see handout and description above)


10
30 Nov
Did Darwin get it all right? Revolutionary insights from genetics & the Galápagos & the fossil record D. McHugh2  

Readings: Appleman text; Dear Mr. Darwin: x-118; Grant's article on Adaptive Radiation of Darwin's Finches: 130-139; Prothero's article on The Fossils Say Yes in Nov 05 Natural History issue on "Darwin & Evolution":52-56 (paper copies to be distributed or available thru Blackboard)

Assignment: How did the discovery of genetics amplify or change Darwin's theory? What kinds of new genetic evidence suggest that factors other than natural selection contribute to the evolutionary process? What are the implications for (and beyond) science?

12
15 Nov
Catch up, review, and prep for the symposium    


13-14
29 Nov,
6 Dec
Student symposium (presentations of final research) + SETs   Final research paper due by 5 pm
on Friday, 7 December


Notes about the invited lecturers (tentative):
    Randal Keynes: first-time author and great-great-grandson of Charlse Darwin; lives in London
    Dr. Damhnait McHugh, G. Kirk Raab '59 Associate Professor of Biology, Colgate

Notes about the reading assignments:

    Assigned readings will form the basis for "jigsaw" discussions (i.e., each of you will read common texts but may also read different selections and then integrate information together from those sources during classroom discussions)




Back to 313Y Syllabus


http://classes.colgate.edu/csoja/darwin/
Questions to: csoja@mail.colgate.edu
Copyright 2002 © Colgate University.
updated 8/07